Poppy’S Pizzeria Reviews, Ratings & Menu | 7 Old Mariaville Rd, Schenectady

General Info

If you’re craving a laid-back pizza spot with a welcoming vibe, Poppy’s Pizzeria is one of those places that feels easy to enjoy from the moment you arrive. Tucked along Old Mariaville Road, this pizza restaurant keeps things simple, approachable, and focused on what matters most-good food and a comfortable experience.

Walking in, the atmosphere feels casual and family-friendly, making it a solid choice if you’re dining with kids or just looking for a relaxed meal. The menu centers around classic pizza options, and while it doesn’t try to overcomplicate things, that’s exactly where its charm lies. Everything feels familiar in a good way-like the kind of place you can return to again and again without overthinking your order.

One thing that stands out is how convenient the services are. If you’re on the go, curbside pickup makes grabbing a quick meal effortless. At the same time, if you prefer to plan ahead, the restaurant accepts reservations, which is always a plus during busy evenings. Payments are smooth too, with debit cards accepted, so there’s no hassle at checkout.

During my visit, I noticed how accommodating the setting is for different types of diners. Families with kids seemed comfortable, and the relaxed seating made it easy to settle in without feeling rushed. Even better, if you’re out with your dog, there’s outdoor space where they’re welcome, which adds a nice touch for pet owners.

What also adds to the overall experience is how the place balances convenience with comfort. It’s not just about the food-it’s about how easy it is to enjoy it. Whether you’re picking up dinner after a long day or sitting down for a casual meal, the flow feels natural and stress-free.

From a reviewer’s perspective, this location stands out not because it tries to be trendy, but because it delivers a dependable, straightforward dining experience. The combination of a clear menu, practical services, and a welcoming environment creates a spot that feels genuinely local.

It’s the kind of pizza restaurant that fits seamlessly into everyday life-easy to access, easy to enjoy, and easy to recommend when someone asks for a reliable place in Schenectady.

What customers say?

“ Just ordered delivery Today Feb16. I live in Scotia and was excited that Poppy’s could deliver to here. Ordered a couple pizzas. A cheese pizza. The sausage, onion, and peppers pizza looked beautiful. The PB&J Wings extra crispy., tastes better than expected. Definitely ordering again from Poppy’s. ”

- Gregory Gannon -

“ Disclaimer, the new owner and I are friends. I loved his food at his previous endeavor, his rolls are heavenly. I wanted to try out the new place but I live out of town. I came into the area to go to a party. I ordered some food from Poppy’s for the party . I brought baked ziti, buffalo wings and a tray of garlic knots. When I showed up at the party, I dropped the food but needed to move the car down the street. Saying hello to people as I made my way to the food table. People kept walking up and complementing the food I brought, I better get a plate! By the time I got to the table, I there were only 2 wings, a little baked ziti and some of the huge garlic knots left. I was glad to get it. Wings were terrific. The knots had some garlic butter. There was extra sauce provided for the pasta. We got some additional HOT sauce for the wings on the side which people poured on some of the other food that was there since it was so good. I wanted to take some pictures of the food, the only thing that I could do was take pictures of mostly empty containers. Let me say it again, short time between drop off and all food was gone. Big thumbs up! ”

- Steve Battiste -

“ The new owners of poppys have done a great job. We love their every day special! Poppys is our new go to pizzeria after trying many places in the area. ”

- Jessica T -

“ We've been wanting to try Poppy's and so glad we finally did--very impressed! Ordered the garlic shrimp specialty 12 cut and it was delicious! We found our new go-to for pizza! ”

- T T -

“ I placed an order through doordash for a pizza and mozzarella sticks. Before I even received the order, Poppy's called me because they realized they accidentally sent me wings instead of mozzarella sticks. Even though I'm probably out of their normal delivery area they offered for me to keep the wings and deliver the mozzarella sticks to me. They were extremely apologetic, both the person that called me and the person that delivered them. Mistakes happen, we're human, it's how we handle them and Poppy's handled it perfectly. Great job Poppy's, thank you. ”

- Erica Godlewski -

“ I had a slice of pepperoni pizza late in the evening it was fresh hot and delicious I recommend this spot. Not to mention the place looks spotless very clean and the owner was there very nice gentleman ”

- mark scaringe -

“ I ordered a ceaser salad with crispy chicken and garlic bread with cheese and meatball sub all fabulous! Thank you will be ordering again. Delicious ”

- denise provost -

“ First time eating there recently, food was phenomenal! Best wings I’ve ever had and even after traveling 20 minutes how they were still saucy and had the perfect crisp!! Will definitely be returning! ”

- Chris Bradt -

Welcome to Poppy’S Pizzeria

General Info

Poppy’S Pizzeria menu

Poppy’S Pizzeria Photos

What customers say?

Location & Contact

See more food places